Tribal Thinking

  • Why Groupthink Works

    In politics (and social life) what one person thinks doesn't matter as much as what the group thinks. If you understand the thinking of the group, you almost always understand the thinking of the individual. The higher the stakes, the more intense the groupthink. The more ambiguous the issue, the greater the individual's reliance on

    read more

  • Red and Blue America

    America is more complex, obviously. But I think it's fair to say that there are two poles that define our politics, and every election cycle we find that we're split rather evenly between them. Call these poles Republican and Democrat or Conservative and Liberal, Reactionary and Progressive, or Red and Blue. They are ways of describing

    read more

  • Retrieving a “Better Angels” Ethos

    This review of Jonathan Haidt's new book The Righteous Mind is worth a read (h/t MMc). In my class we talk a lot about rhetorical technique and how every message has a mix of logos, pathos, and ethos. Universities are logos-centric, but the rest of the world is not. Most people make judgments based on emotion

    read more

  • Competing Tribal Narratives

    From Jonathan Haidt, "Forget the Money, Follow the Sacredness" in Saturday's NYT" A good way to follow the sacredness is to listen to the stories that each tribe tells about itself and the larger nation. The Notre Dame sociologist Christian Smith once summarized the moral narrative told by the American left like this: “Once upon

    read more

  • Tribal America (work in progress)

    Just talking about party affiliation doesn't work anymore, because anybody with any sense realizes the party system doesn't serve the American people anymore. The party system as it exists now is egregiously top heavy and dysfunctional. The current system is neither responsive nor effective; it's a joke. It's made our country ungovernable, and something else

    read more

  • Dying Traditions IIIb: A Dissent & Response

    Mike McG, a long-time ATF reader, from time to time sends me thoughtful dissents. I deeply appreciate that he takes the time and makes the effort to do it.  I got this one last night as a comment in response Dying Traditions IIIb with a message that the site wouldn't let him post it there.

    read more

  • People and Their Mindsets

    I'm getting a few lectures about how wrong it is for me to be so hard on the tea partiers because they are mostly good-hearted folks who hate the bailouts/outsourcing/corporatism just like the rest of us. But that argument makes me feel the same way I felt when people told me that Bush wasn't really

    read more